. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump floated the thought this previous week of utilizing tariffs to make America wealthy, as if these taxes are a pipeline of money from Asia, which they’re not.
He displayed a slippery grasp of science in addition to commerce policy as he set about making an attempt to discredit his White Home report on local weather change. And his description of a producing revival, as if created by a wave of his “magic wand,” was a sleight of hand.
Trump’s penchant for misstatements didn’t cease together with his personal rhetoric. He unfold round to his hundreds of thousands of Twitter followers a wildly false declare that folks within the nation illegally get extra help from the federal authorities than People get in Social Safety advantages. The supposed proof for that was a single occasion of the federal government serving to a refugee household — the Canadian authorities, aiding refugees in Canada.
A take a look at some of his current statements, full with grammatical Twitter errors, and the way they examine with the details:
TRUMP: “Billions of Dollars are pouring into the coffers of the U.S.A. because of the Tariffs being charged to China, and there is a long way to go. If companies don’t want to pay Tariffs, build in the U.S.A. Otherwise, lets just make our Country richer than ever before.” — tweet Thursday.
THE FACTS: That’s not the way it works. Sure, cash from tariffs goes into the federal treasury, nevertheless it’s coming from U.S. companies, not from abroad. Tariffs are paid by the importer, not the exporter or authorities out of the country.
Past that, tariffs paid by U.S. corporations are likely to end in greater costs for shoppers. So a tariff is a switch of wealth from enterprise to authorities, and typically from shoppers to authorities as properly. It isn’t a overseas cost to the U.S.
TRUMP, on the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Commerce Settlement: “The USMCA is the largest, most significant, modern and balanced trade agreement in history. All of our countries will benefit greatly. It is probably the largest trade deal ever made, also. ” — signing ceremony Friday.
THE FACTS: It’s not the most important commerce deal ever made. It covers the identical three nations as its predecessor, NAFTA. In distinction, the Uruguay Spherical of commerce negotiations concluded in 1994 created the World Commerce Group and was signed by 123 nations. The Federal Reserve Financial institution of Boston discovered the next yr that the WTO’s preliminary membership accounted for greater than 90 % of international financial output.
TRUMP, on the pact with Canada and Mexico: “This is a model agreement that changes the trade landscape forever.” He additionally referred to the pact as a “landmark agreement.” — ceremony Friday.
THE FACTS: Truly, the pact preserves the construction and substance of NAFTA, which was unquestionably a landmark, whether or not for higher or worse.
In a single new function, the deal requires that 40 % of automobiles’ contents ultimately be made in nations that pay autoworkers at the very least $16 an hour — that’s, in america and Canada and never in Mexico — to qualify for duty-free remedy. It additionally requires Mexico to pursue an overhaul of labor regulation to encourage unbiased unions that may discount for greater wages and higher working circumstances for Mexicans.
However the settlement is essentially an incremental revision of NAFTA. Philip Levy, senior fellow on the Chicago Council on International Affairs and a commerce official in Republican President George W. Bush’s White Home, says: “President Trump has seriously overhyped this agreement.”
TRUMP: “Remember the previous administration said, oh, manufacturing jobs, that will never happen. I kept saying, what’s he talking about? Manufacturing, we got to make things, right? They said manufacturing jobs would never come back. You’d need a magic wand. Well, we found the magic wand. And they’re great jobs. They’re high-paying jobs. They’re brilliant jobs. They’re important jobs.” — Biloxi, Mississippi, rally Monday.
THE FACTS: No magic wand has swept throughout manufacturing.
Sure, manufacturing jobs have been added underneath Trump, however the sector is nowhere near its previous glory.
As of October, the Bureau of Labor Statistics exhibits that eight.53 % of the 149.eight million U.S. jobs have been in manufacturing. Again in October 2008, 9.65 % of U.S. jobs have been in manufacturing. Even when factories maintain hiring staff, factories are unlikely to return to the prominence of Trump’s childhood as a result of so many different segments of the U.S. financial system — similar to well being care — have grown.
In 1946, the yr Trump was born, almost a 3rd of U.S. staff had manufacturing jobs.
Progress in manufacturing employment started in President Barack Obama’s second time period, when 386,000 jobs have been added, and accelerated underneath Trump, with 416,000 extra jobs in his first 21 months.
TRUMP: “Our steel industry a year ago was dead, and now it’s one of the most vibrant anywhere in the world, because we stopped the steel dumping and we put a big tax on. When they steel dump, they can dump all they want, but they pay 25 percent on everything they dump, and our steel now is doing great. Our industry has come back.” — Mississippi rally.
TRUMP: “Big Steel is opening and renovating plants all over the country.” — tweet Thursday.
THE FACTS: He’s exaggerating the restoration of the metal business.
As of October, there have been 381,700 jobs within the manufacturing of main metals resembling metal. That determine seesaws based mostly off commodity costs and international financial efficiency. However it’s clearly trended downward since 2000 when the sector had 621,800 jobs.
It’s troublesome to know simply what number of jobs shall be added by newly deliberate mills. However development spending on factories has but to take off considerably after having been in decline between 2016 and far of 2018. Nonetheless, the spending has rebounded in current months. Development spending on factories has elevated four.three % up to now yr, in response to the Census Bureau.
A yr in the past, the metal business employed 141,200 individuals, says the Labor Division. Now, 145,100. That’s a achieve of three,900 jobs throughout a interval when the general financial system added 2.5 million jobs.
Metal wasn’t at demise’s door a yr in the past and it isn’t “back” in any historic sense.
TRUMP: “General Motors is very counter to what other auto, and other companies are doing. Big Steel is opening and renovating plants all over the country. Auto companies are pouring into the U.S., including BMW, which just announced a major new plant. The U.S.A. is booming!” — tweet Thursday.
THE FACTS: This auto business growth doesn’t exist.
Automakers have been steadily hiring since 2010 when Obama was president. However the tempo of job good points has slowed significantly since Trump took workplace, in line with the Labor Division. That’s in all probability a mirrored image of slowing gross sales fairly than any policy modifications by Trump.
U.S. auto gross sales are down zero.2 % via October largely as a result of of a 13 % plunge in automotive gross sales. Truck and SUV gross sales are up eight %. All of the factories GM needs to shut make slow-selling automobiles.
The Labor Division discovered that automakers added 30,600 jobs throughout Obama’s final yr in workplace. That fell to eight,200 in 2017 after Trump turned president. Automakers have been on tempo earlier than the GM layoffs so as to add eight,660 jobs this yr.
Regardless of the job progress in recent times, auto corporations make use of far fewer staff than they did in 2000. Greater than 1.three million individuals held auto jobs in 2000, a complete that now stands at roughly 970,000.
Common Motors Co. isn’t alone in chopping staff. Crosstown rival Ford Motor Co. is simply beginning to restructure its white-collar workforce, and hundreds are anticipated to be let go by the center of subsequent yr.
Additionally, BMW didn’t announce a serious new plant. Its CEO stated Tuesday the corporate is contemplating a brand new U.S. engine manufacturing unit to provide meeting crops in South Carolina and Mexico. The German automaker now imports engines and transmissions from Europe for SUVs made within the U.S., and it’s constructing a brand new manufacturing unit in Mexico.
TRUMP: “You look at our air and our water and it’s right now at a record clean.” — interview Tuesday with The Washington Submit.
THE FACTS: No, the air isn’t the cleanest ever. The air usually has been getting cleaner because the 1970s, however the downward development in air pollution has made a bit of a U-turn since Trump took workplace.
His Environmental Safety Company launched knowledge that confirmed conventional air air pollution — soot and smog — elevated in 2017 and that the air just isn’t the cleanest it has ever been.
The times with an unhealthy quantity of small air pollution particles, typically referred to as soot and linked to coronary heart and lung issues and deaths, jumped from 2016 to 2017 in 35 main metropolitan areas. In 2017, there have been 179 unhealthy soot days, up 85 % from 97 in 2016. Final yr had probably the most unhealthy soot days since 2011.
The quantity of days with unhealthy smog ranges was down from 2016, however greater than 2015, 2014 and 2013.
The quantity of days when the air high quality index was unhealthy was 729 in 2017. The quantity of days is larger than a yr as a result of it counts every metropolis’s unhealthy studying on a sure day as one and there are quite a few cities concerned.
Final yr’s degree was the very best since 2012 and a 21 % improve over the cleanest air in 2014.
TRUMP: “I mean, we take thousands of tons of garbage off our beaches all the time that comes over from Asia. It just flows right down the Pacific, it flows, and we say where does this come from?” — Publish interview.
THE FACTS: Singling out Asia for America’s soiled Pacific seashores is an evasion.
Pacific currents do deliver some trash from Asia, most noticeably in the course of the 2011 tsunami, however it’s uncommon that scientists can hint trash to a selected geographic location, stated oceanographer Kara Lavender Regulation on the Sea Schooling Affiliation, who stated Trump’s “statement is not supported by the data.”
People soiled their very own coastlines as a result of “we produce double more trash per person than most of the people living in Southeast Asia,” stated Jenna Jambeck, a College of Georgia environmental engineering professional who research marine particles.
SARAH HUCKABEE SANDERS, on Trump rejecting a dire White Home report’s conclusion on the financial prices of local weather change: “This report is based on the most extreme modeled scenario, which contradicts long-established trends. …This is the most extreme version and it’s not based on facts.” — press briefing Tuesday.
THE FACTS: She’s improper. The 29-chapter report truly lays out numerous situations that the United Nations’ local weather assessments use. Economists say the fee estimates are credible and should even understate the financial influence.
The Nationwide Local weather Evaluation report considers three situations in estimating future prices. One is the business-as-usual state of affairs, which scientists say is closest to the present state of affairs. That’s the worst case of the three situations. One other would envision modest reductions in heat-trapping gases, and the third would contain extreme cuts in carbon dioxide air pollution.
For instance, underneath the business-as-usual state of affairs by which emissions of heat-trapping gasses proceed at present ranges, labor prices in outside industries throughout warmth waves might value $155 billion in misplaced wages per yr by 2090. Modest reductions in carbon air pollution would reduce that to $75 billion a yr, the report stated.
The report talks of a whole lot of billions of dollars in financial losses in a number of spots. In a single graphic, it exhibits the worst-case business-as-usual state of affairs of financial prices reaching 10 % of gross home product when Earth is a few dozen levels hotter than now with no particular date.
Economist Ray Kopp, a vice chairman on the assume tank Assets For the Future and who wasn’t half of the evaluation, stated the economics and the science within the report have been sound.
Yale economist William Nordhaus, who gained the 2018 Nobel prize for economics for his work on local weather change, advised The Related Press that his calculations present local weather change would value america a good larger $four trillion a yr on the finish of the century with an inexpensive projection of warming. He stated the White Home report’s financial conclusions used commonplace financial modeling.
TRUMP, on the confrontation between migrants making an attempt to hurry into the U.S. and authorities who used tear fuel to drive them again: “Three Border Patrol people yesterday were very badly hurt, getting hit with rocks and stones.” — remarks to reporters Monday.
THE FACTS: This didn’t occur, based on the account by the commissioner of Customs and Border Safety, Kevin McAleenan. He stated there have been no “reported serious injuries on either side of the border” and “Four agents were hit with rocks, but were wearing protective gear and did not suffer serious injuries.”
TRUMP’s retweet: “Illegals can get up to $3,874 a month under Federal Assistance program. Our social security checks are on average $1200 a month. RT (retweet) if you agree: If you weren’t born in the United States, you should receive $0 assistance.” — posted Wednesday.
THE FACTS: Improper nation, improper numbers, mistaken description of authorized standing of the recipients. In addition to that, immigrants who’re within the U.S. illegally don’t qualify for many federal advantages, even once they’re paying taxes, and people with authorized standing make up a small portion of those that use public advantages.
The $three,874 refers to a cost made in Canada, not the U.S., to a legally admitted household of refugees. It was largely a one-time resettlement cost underneath Canada’s refugee program, not month-to-month help in perpetuity, the fact-checking website Snopes discovered a yr in the past in debunking a Fb submit that misrepresented Canada’s policy. A doc cited within the Fb publish, displaying assist for meals, transportation and different fundamentals wants, utilized to a household of 5.
Aside from complicated Canada with america, the tweet distributed by the president misstated how a lot People get from Social Safety on common — $1,419 a month for retired staff, not $1,200.
General, low-income immigrants who are usually not but U.S. residents use Medicaid, meals help, money help and Supplemental Safety Revenue assist at a decrease fee than comparable U.S.-born adults, in response to an Related Press evaluation of census knowledge. Non-citizen immigrants make up solely 6.5 % of all these collaborating in Medicaid, for instance.
Regardless of that, the administration needs to redefine the principles for immigrants to additional prohibit who can obtain advantages and for a way lengthy.
TRUMP: “Obama had a separation policy; we all had the same policy. I tried to do it differently, but Obama had a separation policy. But people don’t like to talk about that.” — remarks to reporters Monday.
TRUMP: “@60Minutes did a phony story about child separation when they know we had the exact same policy as the Obama Administration. In fact a picture of children in jails was used by other Fake Media to show how bad (cruel) we are, but it was in 2014 during O years. Obama separated … children from parents, as did Bush etc., because that is the policy and law. I tried to keep them together but the problem is, when you do that, vast numbers of additional people storm the Border. So with Obama seperation is fine, but with Trump it’s not. Fake 60 Minutes!” — tweets Sunday.
THE FACTS: Obama didn’t have a separation policy. The Trump administration didn’t, explicitly, both, however that was the impact of his zero tolerance policy, which meant that anybody caught crossing the border illegally was to be criminally prosecuted, even when that they had few or no earlier offences.
The policy meant adults have been taken to courtroom for legal proceedings and their youngsters have been separated. Usually, if the cost took longer than 72 hours to course of, which is the longest time that youngsters might be held by Customs and Border Safety, youngsters have been despatched into the care of the Well being and Human Providers Division. Zero tolerance stays in impact, however Trump signed an government order June 20 that stopped separations.
The president is right, nevertheless, in saying that photographs of youngsters in holding cells have been misrepresented on-line as displaying the consequences of Trump’s immigration policy.
The photographs, taken by The Related Press, have been from 2014, in the course of the Obama administration, and confirmed youngsters who got here to the border with out their mother and father and have been being housed at a Customs and Border Safety middle in Nogales, Arizona. The pictures have been recognized as such however wrongly described on-line as illustrating imprisonment underneath Trump. Numerous activists expressed horror concerning the scene till it was identified that Trump had nothing to do with it.
Related Press writers Josh Boak, Christopher Rugaber, Seth Borenstein and Colleen Lengthy in Washington and Tom Krisher in Detroit contributed to this report.
Discover AP Reality Checks at http://apne.ws/2kbx8bd
Comply with @APFactCheck on Twitter: https://twitter.com/APFactCheck
EDITOR’S NOTE _ A take a look at the veracity of claims by political figures